Research Article

A Study on the Type of Constructive Speech Formats in Value Debate —Focusing the Logic Structure of Stock Issues

Min Hyoung Lee

한국교육과정평가원

Published: January 2015 · Vol. 50, No. 3 · pp. 121-160

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20880/kler.2015.50.3.121

Abstract

In the current study, an attempt was made to create constructive speech formats of the proposition of value debate as a starting point for research on the proposition of value debate. An appropriate constructive speech format was proposed by analyzing the logical structure of stock issues. The current study classified constructive speech format into the following types: sporadic presentation of reasons, stock issue reflection, criteria justification, value application suggestion.

Keywords: 국어교육가치 논제가치 논제 토론화법교육토론필수쟁점입론 형식

REFERENCES (27)

[1]
[1] [단행본] 국어교육을 위한 의사소통 이론/박재현/(주)사회평론/2013/~/// Google Scholar ›
[2]
[2] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박재현/정책 토론의 입론 구성 교육 내용 연구/우리말글/2014/60/93~121/우리말글학회/ Google Scholar ›
[3]
[3] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박재현/초·중·고 학생의 정책 토론 입론 양상 분석 -피해와 내재성 쟁점을 중심으로-/화법연구/2014/(25)/159~187/한국화법학회/10.18625/jsc.2014..25.159 Google Scholar ›
[4]
[4] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이민형/예비 교사들의 훈화 내용 구성 양상:가치 연설의 특성을 중심으로/화법연구/2015/(28)/61~104/한국화법학회/ Google Scholar ›
[5]
[5] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이선영/토론 교육을 위한 논제 선정에 대한 소고(小考)－국내․외 토론 대회 논제 분석을 중심으로－/청람어문교육/2010/(41)/241~267/청람어문교육학회/ Google Scholar ›
[6]
[6] [학위논문] 이선영/토론 교육 내용 체계 연구 : 초·중·고 토론대회 담화 분석을 바탕으로/박사/서울대학교/국어교육/2011 Google Scholar ›
[7]
[7] [단행본] 말과 권력: 레토릭에서 의사소통 민주주의로/이준웅/한길사/2011/~/// Google Scholar ›
[8]
[8] [학술지(정기간행물)] 추정훈/사회과에서의 가치교육의 문제/사회과교육연구/2005/12(2)/237~261/한국사회교과교육학회/ Google Scholar ›
[9]
[9] [인터넷자원] Logic in LD: Part II Casing application/http://www.nflonline.org/Rostrum/Ld1104Baldwin////2004 Google Scholar ›
[10]
[10] [단행본] Non-policy debating/Berube, D. M./Univ Pr of Amer/1994/~/// Google Scholar ›
[11]
[11] [단행본] The debater’s guide/Ericson, J. M./SIU Press/2011/~/// Google Scholar ›
[12]
[12] [단행본] Prima facie: a guide to value debate/Gill, A./Kendall Hunt Pub Co/1989/~///Affirmative Case Approaches Google Scholar ›
[13]
[13] [단행본] The art and practice of argumentation and debate/Hill, B./McGraw-Hill Humanities/1996/~/// Google Scholar ›
[14]
[14] [단행본] Critical thinking and communication: the use of reason in argument/Inch, E. S./Pearson Education, Inc/2006/~/// Google Scholar ›
[15]
[15] [학술지(정기간행물)] Matlon, R. J./Debating Propositions of Value/Journal of the American Forensic Association/1978/14(4)/194~204// Google Scholar ›
[16]
[16] [단행본] The Art of Value Debate: A Study in Understanding and Discussing Values/Pitchford, M./Communicators Advantage Project, Inc/2008/~/// Google Scholar ›
[17]
[17] [단행본] The Value Debate Handbook/Pork, L./Baylor Briefs/2000/~/// Google Scholar ›
[18]
[18] [단행본] Moving from policy to value debate/Richards, J. A./National Textbook Company/1992/~/// Google Scholar ›
[19]
[19] [단행본] The nature of human values(Vol. 438)/Rokeach, M./Free press/1973/~/// Google Scholar ›
[20]
[20] [기타자료] Scott, R. J./A stock issues-based paradigm for value proposition debate (Order No. 8918954)/ProQuest Dissertations & Theses A&I. (303820055)/1989/~// Google Scholar ›
[21]
[21] [단행본] 논변의 사용/Toulmin, S./고려대학교 출판부/2003/~/// Google Scholar ›
[22]
[22] [학술지(정기간행물)] Tuman, J. S./Getting to First Base : Prima Facie Arguments for Propositions of Value/Journal of the American Forensic Association/1987/24(2)/84~94// Google Scholar ›
[23]
[23] [학술지(정기간행물)] Warnick, B./Arguing Value Propositions/Journal of the American Forensic Association/1981/18(2)/109~119// Google Scholar ›
[24]
[24] [단행본] Lincoln-Douglas Debate: Values in Conflict/Wiese, J./Clark Pub/2000/~/// Google Scholar ›
[25]
[25] [단행본] Values and policies in controversy: An introduction to argumentation and debate/Wilbanks, C./Hunt Publishing Company/1991/~/// Google Scholar ›
[26]
[26] [단행본] 논증의 탄생: 글쓰기의 새로운 전략/Williams, J./홍문관/2008/~/// Google Scholar ›
[27]
[27] [단행본] Argumentation: Inquiry and advocacy/Ziegelmueller, G. W/Allyn and Bacon/1997/~/// Google Scholar ›

Publication History

Published 2015-01-01

Metrics

Cited by 7