Argumentation Narrated by Experiencing Self and Narrating Self of Persuasive Experience Narrative
Ji Seoyoung
서울대학교 국어교육과
Korea Business Review 56Vol. 4No. pp.413-436 (2021)
Abstract
This article aims to provide a new perspective of experience narrative for persuasive purpose, vastly underexplored, requesting an argumentative explanation beyond the narrative one generally acknowledges. At the beginning, we shall clarify the concept of ‘experience’ - perception or recall. The perception, called ‘real perception’, is different from ‘real events’ or ‘recalled perception’. Experience narrative structurally identical with experience are structured by narrative self and experiencing self. Experiencing self at the time of event results in perception and narrating self at the time of narrating performs recall. The two selves are the two subjects of structuring the meaning of the narrative, and at the same time the subjects of macro-communication. The two selves narrate argumentation trying to persuade that the narrated perception is ‘fact’. The ‘fact’ of the experience narrative is not a question of whether the described perception coincides with ‘recovered perception’, ‘real perception’, or ‘real fact’(which refers to ‘fact’ in a general sense), but a question of whether the audience approves the described perception as ‘fact’. Therefore, argumentation depends on audience’s approval. Experiencing self narrates perception, and narrating self reconstructs the perception to achieve the purpose of argumentation. If audience disapproves, narrating self come to the front to supplement or justify the perception.
Keywords
논증논증행위설득경험 서사경험경험자아서술자아
References
- [1] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김정란/자기 표현적 글쓰기의 비판적 검토와 지도 방향 모색/작문연구/2014/(20)/199~229/한국작문학회/
- [2] [학술지(정기간행물)] 민병곤/논증 이론의 현황과 국어 교육의 과제/국어교육학연구/2001/12/237~285//
- [3] [학위논문] 민병곤/논증 교육의 내용 연구 : 6, 8, 10학년 학습자의 작문 및 토론 분석을 바탕으로/박사/서울대학교 대학원/국어교육/2004
- [4] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박용익/이야기란 무엇인가?/텍스트언어학/2006/20/141~161/한국텍스트언어학회/
- [5] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이종우/후설 현상학에서 재기억의 명증 문제에 관하여/철학논구/2015/42/271~294//
- [6] [단행본] 서사표현교육론연구/임경순/역락/2003/~///
- [7] [단행본] 화법 용어 해설/한국화법학회 화법용어해설위원회/박이정/2014/~///
- [8] [단행본] 논거와 논증: 논증 분석의 논리적 토대/Bayer, K./HUiNE/2019/~///
- [9] [단행본] 영국 경험론: 홉즈에서 흄까지/Copleston, F. C./서광사/1991/~///
- [10] [단행본] 텍스트학/Dijk, T. A./아르케/2001/~///
- [11] [인터넷자원] 14년 전 대표팀 구타 첫 폭로…○○○ 선수/https://news.jtbc.joins.com/article/article.aspx?news_id=NB11743868/JTBC/2021//2018
- [12] [인터넷자원] “내 몸이 증거”… 가습기 살균제 피해자 ○○○ 씨/https://news.jtbc.joins.com/article/article.aspx?news_id=NB11987963/JTBC/2021//2021
- [13] [단행본] Thinking, fast and slow, Manhattan/Kahneman, D./Farrar, Straus and Giroux/2011/~///
- [14] [단행본] 이야기 분석: 서사적 정체성의 재구성과 서사 인터뷰의 분석을 위한 이론과 방법론/Lucius-Hoene, G./역락/2011/~///
- [15] [단행본] 한낮의 우울/Solomon, A./민음사/2014/~///
- [16] [단행본] 인지심리학/Sternberg, R. J./박학사/2016/~///
- [17] [단행본] 소통: 협력적인 의사소통의 방법-사회구성주의적 접근/Stewart, J./커뮤니케이션북스/2015/~///
