초등학생 필자의 독자 고려 정도와 방식
정혜승
경인교육대학교
Korea Business Review 34호 397-427 (2009)
초록
이 연구는 초등학생 필자가 글을 쓸 때 독자를 어느 정도로, 어떤 방식으로 고려하는지를 분석하는 데 목적이 있다. 연구 목적을 달성하기 위하여 1) 초등학생 필자는 독자를 어느 정도로 고려하는가? 2) 초등학생 필자가 독자를 고려하는 주된 방식은 무엇인가? 3) 학년에 따라 초등학생 필자가 독자를 고려하는 정도와 방식이 달라지는가? 4) 예상 독자에 따라 초등학생 필자의 독자 고려 정도와 방식이 달라지는가? 5) 학년에 따라 초등학생 필자가 예상 독자를 고려하는 정도와 방식이 달라지는가? 등의 연구 문제를 설정하고, 서울과 경기 지역의 3개 초등학교의 2, 4, 6학년 294명을 대상으로 고쳐 쓰기 과제를 투입하고, 학생들의 글을 수사적 이동을 기준으로 분석하였다. 분석 결과 초등학생 필자들은 전반적으로 독자를 고려하는 정도가 미약하고, 주로 끌어들이기 방식을 중심으로 독자를 고려하고 있음을 알게 되었다. 학생들의 글은 특히 정보 조절하기와 반응에 대처하기 이동에서 낮은 빈도를 보이는데, 이는 학생들이 독자의 배경지식을 고려하여 글 속 정보를 조절하거나, 독자의 반응을 예상하여 그에 적절하게 대처하는 전략을 구사하는 능력이 부족함을 뜻한다. 그러나 이 연구의 결과로 초등학생 필자가 독자를 고려하는 능력이 부족하다는 결론을 내리기보다는 동료 독자를 비롯한 현실적 독자와의 사회적 상호작용이 활성화된 쓰기 환경과 상호교섭적이고 실제적인 쓰기 과제를 제공하여 독자 고려 능력을 제고하는 교육적 노력이 필요하다.
키워드
독자 고려학생 필자예상 독자독자 고려 방식수사적 이동독자 고려 단서독자 고려 전략고쳐 쓰기
참고문헌
- [1] [학위논문] 박민경/독자 고려하기가 쓰기에 미치는 효과에 관한 연구/석사/고려대학교//2008
- [2] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박영민/과학영역의 작문에서 예상독자 유형과 은유의 전략/국어교육학연구/2003/16(16)/189~224/국어교육학회/
- [3] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박영민/작문 교육에서 예상독자의 인식과 처리/청람어문교육/2004/29(29)/135~160/청람어문교육학회/
- [4] [학술지(정기간행물)] 박영민/학생 작문의 다니엘 효과와 예상독자 인식의 방법/새국어교육/2005/70(70)/73~99/한국국어교육학회/
- [5] [학위논문] 유상희/쓰기 과정에서 필자의 독자 고려 양상 연구-대학생의 사고 구술 자료를 바탕으로/석사/고려대학교//2008
- [6] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이아라/글쓰기 과정의 '숨은 독자(Hidden Reader)'-글쓰기 과정에서 독자의 새로운 작용에 관한 새로운 이해-/국어교육학연구/2008/31(31)/393~435/국어교육학회/
- [7] [학술지(정기간행물)] 정희모/글쓰기에서 독자의 의미와 기능/새국어교육/2008/79(79)/393~418/한국국어교육학회/
- [8] [단행본] A Sense of Audience in Written Communication in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Roth,R.G//1990/175~187///
- [9] [학술지(정기간행물)] Berkenkotter, C/Understanding a Writer’s Awareness of Audience,College Composition and/Communication/1981/32/388~399//
- [10] [단행본] The Development of Writing Abilities,Illinois:National Council of Teachers of English,pp/Britton, J./National Council of Teachers of English/1975/11~18///
- [11] [단행본] Audience Expectations and Teacher Demands/Brooke, R/Southern Illinois University Press/1989/~///
- [12] [단행본] Common-core and Specific Approaches to the Teaching of Academic Writing in Academic Writing in a Second Language/Dudley-Evans, T/Ablex/1995/293~312///
- [13] [학술지(정기간행물)] Ede, L/Audience Addressed/Audience Invoked:The Role of Audience in Composition Theory and Pedagogy/College Composition and Communication/1984/35(2)/155~171//
- [14] [학술지(정기간행물)] Ede, L./Audience:An Introduction to Research/College Composition and Communication/1984/35(2)/140~154//
- [15] [학술지(정기간행물)] Elbow, P./My eyes as I Speak:An Argument for Ignoring Audience/College English/1987/49(1)/50~69//
- [16] [학술지(정기간행물)] Flower, L/The Cognition of Discovery:Defining a Rhetorical Problem/College Composition and Communication/1980/31(1)/21~32//
- [17] [학술대회논문] Fontaine, S. I./Audience Awareness and the Interpersonal Function of Writing/Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Conference on College Composition and Communication/1987//~/
- [18] [학술지(정기간행물)] Frank, L. A./Writing to Be Read:Young Writer’s Ability to Demonstrate Audience Awareness When Evaluated by Their Readers/Research in the Teaching of English/1992/26(3)/277~298//
- [19] [단행본] Argumentative Writing of Students:Adult Socio-Cognitive Development in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Hays, J. N./Sage Publications/1990/248~266///
- [20] [단행본] Introduction:Theories and research on audience in written communication in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Kirsch, G/Sage Publications/1990/13~21///
- [21] [단행본] Experienced Writers’ Sense of Audience and authority in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Kirsch, G./Sage Publications/1990/216~230///
- [22] [학술지(정기간행물)] Kroll, B. M./Writing for Readers:Three Perspectives on Audience/College Composition and Communication/1984/35(2)/172~185//
- [23] [단행본] The Writer’s Audience:Fact or Fiction? in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Long, R. C./Sage Publications/1990/73~84///
- [24] [단행본] ESL Students’ Use of Audience in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Mangelsdorf, K/Sage Publications/1990/231~247///
- [25] [학술지(정기간행물)] Many, J. E/Developing a Sense of Audience:An Examination of one school’s instructional contexts/Reading Horizon/2005/45(4)/321~348//
- [26] [학술지(정기간행물)] McAlexander, P. J./Ideas in Practice:Audience Awareness and Developmental Composition/Journal of Developmental Education/1996/20(1)/28~33//
- [27] [학술지(정기간행물)] Monahan, B. D./Revision Strategies of Basic and Competent Writers as They Write for Different Audiences/Research in the Teaching of English/1984/18/288~304//
- [28] [단행본] Rhetoric’s “Audience” and Linguistics’ “Speech Community”:Implications for Understanding Writing, Reading, and Text in What Writers Know:The Language, Process, and Structure of Written Discourse/Nystrand, M./Academic Press/1982/1~28///
- [29] [학술지(정기간행물)] Oswald, R. A./The Story of Molly:Using Audience Awareness In a Second-Grade Writers’ Workshop/Ohio Reading teacher/2002/35(2)/20~27//
- [30] [학술지(정기간행물)] Park, D. B./The Meanings of “Audience”/College English/1982/44(3)/247~257//
- [31] [학술지(정기간행물)] Piché, G. L/Social Cognition and Writing:Interpersonal Cognitive Complexity and Abstractness and Quality of students’Persuasive Writing/Written Communication/1987/4/69~89//
- [32] [단행본] Audience and Rhetoric/Porter, J. E/Englewood Cliffs/1992/~///
- [33] [학술지(정기간행물)] Rafoth, B. A./Audience Adaptation in the Essays of Proficient and Nonproficient Freshman Writers/Research in the Teaching of English/1985/19/237~253//
- [34] [단행본] The Concept of Discourse Community:Descriptive and Explanatory Adequacy in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Rafoth, B. A./Sage Publications/1990/140~152///
- [35] [학술지(정기간행물)] Roth, R.G/The Evolving Audience:Alternatives to Audience Accommodation/College Composition and Communication/1987/38(1)/47~55//
- [36] [단행본] Facilitation of Audience Awareness:Revision Processes of Basic Writers in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Rubin, D. L/Sage Publications/1990/280~292///
- [37] [학술지(정기간행물)] Rubin, D. L/Social Cognitive Ability as a Predictor of the Quality of Expository and Persuasive Writing Among College Freshmen/Research in the Teaching of English/1986/20/9~21//
- [38] [학술지(정기간행물)] Rubin, D. L./Social Cognition and Written Communication/Written Communication/1984/1/211~245//
- [39] [단행본] Audience Considerations for Evaluating Writing in Evaluating Writing/Ryder, P. M./National Council Of Teachers of English/1999/93~113///
- [40] [단행본] An investigation of the ability of sixth graders to write with sense of audience, Dissertation/Strange, R. L./Indiana University/1986/~///
- [41] [단행본] Pre-Classical Roots of the Addressed/Invoked Dichotomy of Audience in A Sense of Audience in Written Communication/Willey, R. J./Sage Publications/1990/25~39///
- [42] [학술지(정기간행물)] Wolldman-Bonilla, J. E./Can First-Grade Writers Demonstrate Audience Awareness?/Reading Research Quarterly/2001/36(2)/184~201//
