Developing the Reading and Writing Diagnosis Tools for the 1st and 2nd Grade Elementary School Students from Multicultural Family
Min, Byeonggon Hiwon Yoon Ahn Hyeon-gi
경인교육대학교 서울대학교
Korea Business Review 37No. pp.313-346 (2010)
Abstract
The present study aims to describe the process of development and verification of examination tools specially designed for diagnosing the basic reading and writing abilities of the 1st grade and 2nd grade students in elementary schools from multicultural family and suggest applications of those tools. A reading section for the 1st graders consists of 20 items in all and is classified into two parts;decoding Hangul and understanding the meaning of words and decoding sentences and understanding passages. A reading section for the 2nd graders consists of 25 items in all and is classified into four parts;decoding Hangul, understanding the meaning of words, factual understanding, and inferential and critical understanding. A writing section for the 1st graders has 20 items and is made up of two parts like sentence writing and paragraph writing, while a writing section for the 2nd graders has 25 items and consists of four parts;writing a word, writing a sentence, preparing a composition, and expressing and presenting one’s thoughts. We first developed twice the number of questions and, after conducting a pilot test, we confirmed the actual examination questions to be used based on the results of administering the Item Discrimination and Item Difficulty methods. The main examination was administered to a total of 282 students who are either the 1st or 2nd graders of 13 different elementary schools in cities or small towns, including 115 students from multicultural family and 167 students who are not. After grading, we set a criterion score of each subject on the basis of the Item Response Analysis method. The criterion score of the reading section for the 1st graders was 50 points. The average score of the students from multicultural family was 81.66 and that of students from non-multicultural family was 87.26. The criterion score of the reading section for the 2nd graders was set 39 points. The students from non-multicultural family scored 82.42 and have a lead of 16.24 points over the students from multicultural family with an average score of 66.18. The result of a statistical analysis showed that there was a significant difference in average score between the two types of families for both graders. We set a criterion score of the writing section for the 1st graders as 57 points. The students from multicultural family received an average score of 77.78 and the students from non-multicultural family, 82.49. The criterion score for the 2nd graders was 45 points. The students from multicultural family gained 69.89, while those from non-multicultural family, 83.54. We analyzed this average difference statistically and found that only the 2nd grade students showed a significant difference between the two types of families. On the other hand, there was no significant difference between city and small town in average scores obtained by the students from multicultural family, regardless of grade or subject. It was noteworthy that the reading and writing section results showed a significant difference in accordance with the Korean proficiency level of student’s mother in multicultural family. We lastly proposed the followings as limits of our study as well as prospective topics for further studies;a large-scaled sampling for the more reliable test development, an analysis of future changes over years, development of diverse diagnosis tools, development of teaching-aids specially designed for the students from multicultural family, and designing diverse ways for promoting and application of the developed diagnosis tools.
Keywords
국어 교육다문화 교육읽기 교육쓰기 교육기초 학력검사 도구
References
- [1] [학술지(정기간행물)] 강연욱/아동용 언어기억검사(Seoul Verbal Learning Test-Children's version)의 제작과 표준화 연구/한국심리학회지 임상/2003/22(2)/435~448/한국임상심리학회/
- [2] [단행본] 초등학교 교육과정 해설 Ⅲ:국어, 도덕, 사회/교육과학기술부/교육과학기술부/2007/~///
- [3] [단행본] 국민의 기초 문해력 조사/국립국어원/국립국어원/2008/~///
- [4] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김경철/프로젝트 스펙트럼(Project Spectrum)의 언어 평가 도구 타당화를 위한 기초 연구/유아교육연구/2001/821(3)/81~93//
- [5] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김동일/초등학교 저학년 쓰기 저성취 아동 진단을 위한 쓰기 능력 변인 탐색/특수교육학연구/2008/43(1)/109~126/한국특수교육학회/
- [6] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김은정/초등학생용 인지적ㆍ정의적 학습양식 검사도구의 개발 및 타당화/초등교육연구/2008/21(2)/259~279/한국초등교육학회/
- [7] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김정기/한국판 캘리포니아 언어학습검사(K-CVLT) 제작을 위한 타당도 연구/한국심리학회지:임상/1994/13(1)/82~96//
- [8] [보고서] 초등학교 1, 2학년 성취기준 및 평가기준 개발/김정호/한국교육과정평가원/1999/~/연구보고 RRC 99-5
- [9] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김태련/한국아동의 VMI-3R발달검사 규준에 관한 예비연구/한국심리학회지:발달/1995/8(1)/12~21//
- [10] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김태련/한국아동의 VMI-3R 발달검사 규준에 관한 예비연구 Ⅱ:타당도를 중심으로/한국심리학회지:발달/1996/9(2)/20~29//
- [11] [보고서] 2007년 초등학교 3학년 국가수준 기초학력 진단평가 연구:종합/남명호/한국교육과정평가원/2008/~/연구보고 CRE 2008-5-1
- [12] [보고서] 기초 학습기능검사 개발 연구/박경숙/한국교육개발원/1987/~/연구보고 RR 87-42
- [13] [보고서] KISE-기초학력검사(KISE-BAAT) 개발연구/박경숙/국립특수교육원/2004/~/
- [14] [단행본] 다문화가정 학생 대상 언어·인지 진단도구 개발/안현기/교육과학기술부/2009/~///
- [15] [학술지(정기간행물)] 양명희/초등학교 3학년 기초학력 진단평가에 대한 몇 가지 고찰: 개념, 평가 및 활용방법을 중심으로/초등교육연구/2004/17(2)/253~268/한국초등교육학회/
- [16] [학술지(정기간행물)] 염은열/읽기 기초학력 평가를 위한 선결 과제/국어교육학연구/2005/21(22)/213~242/국어교육학회/
- [17] [보고서] 초등학생의 언어능력 발달에 관한 연구/이재분/한국교육개발원/2001/~/연구보고 RR 2001-2-1
- [18] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이재승/읽기 기초 학력 평가의 중요성과 방향/한국어문교육/2003/12/25~46//
- [19] [학술지(정기간행물)] 이주섭/초등학교 3학년의 읽기쓰기 기초 학력에 대한 분석-2002 국가수준 기초학력 진단평가 결과를 중심으로-/독서연구/2004/-(11)/301~326/한국독서학회/
- [20] [보고서] 2004년 초등학교 3학년 국가수준 기초학력 진단평가 연구/정구향/한국교육과정평가원/2005/~/연구리포트 2005
- [21] [학술지(정기간행물)] 천경록/독서 능력 표준화 검사 도구의 연구 개발/독서연구/2006/(15)/425~456/한국독서학회/
- [22] [단행본] Fundamental considerations in language testing/Bachman, L. F./Oxford University Press/1990/~///
- [23] [단행본] Language testing in practice/Bachman, L. F./Oxford University Press/1996/~///
- [24] [학술지(정기간행물)] Craig, A. P./Psychological testing in a multicultural society:universal or particular competencies?/Intercultural Education/2002/13(2)/201~213//
- [25] [단행본] Validation of a diagnostic interpretation technique for the Iowa tests of basic skills:final report to the National Institute of Education/Cummings, O. W./Grant Wood Area Education Agency/1981/~///
- [26] [학술지(정기간행물)] Gonzalez, V./Influence of cognitive, linguistic, and sociocultural factors on literacy and biliteracy in young bilingual children/Education/1994/115(2)/230~239//
- [27] [학술지(정기간행물)] Plenge, T. F./A cooperative assessment strategy for evaluating school-aged children with language impairments/Journal of Learning Disabilities/1988/21(9)/551~1561//
- [28] [학술지(정기간행물)] Rumbaut, R. G./Linguistic life expectancies:immigrant language retention in Southern California/Population and Development Review/2006/32(3)/447~460//
