Children’s Sensitivity to the Plausibility and Moral Features of Stories in Korean Language Arts Class
Koo Yeong-san
한국교육과정평가원
Korea Business Review 45No. pp.135-167 (2012)
Abstract
I conducted fieldwork in a third-grade elementary Korean language arts classroom from March 2009 to February 2010, in order to understand the essence of Korea language arts class (KLAC). I tried to identify significant phenomena that characterize KLAC. It turned out that many students in the classroom were against the privileged interpretation of stories in textbook—I called this “a revolt discourse”. There are two characteristics of the phenomenon. One is that some students were against deriving morals from impossible or implausible stories, such as when a bug suddenly becomes a butterfly in “Narae and Tulduri”(impossible) or when two brothers threw away gold to preserve their love for each other in “Two Brothers Throwing away Gold”(implausible). The other characteristic of the phenomenon is that some students were against deriving morals from perceived immoral behavior such as when a cloth-cutter lied to the king in “The Emperor has no clothes” or when the heroin jumped into the sea leaving behind her blind father in “Shimcheongjeon”. In understanding and judging the dilemma in a so-called “figured world”, students appeal to two criteria, “possibility/plausibility” and “morality”. This is an important phenomenon in KLAC. “A revolt discourse” does not merely involve being against the privileged interpretation of stories in textbooks, but taking a position from which to analyze the story and relate it to reality.
Keywords
의미망으로서의 국어수업지배적 해석에 대한 배반실현가능성도덕성현실 인식대안 담론
References
- [1] [기타자료] /제7차 국어과 교육과정///~//
- [2] [단행본] 초등학교 3-1 / 3-2 《국어 말하기・듣기》, 《국어 읽기》, 《국어 쓰기》//대한 교과서 주식회사//~///
- [3] [기타자료] /초등학교 3-1 / 3-2 《교사용 지도서》/교육인적자원부//~//
- [4] [학위논문] 구영산/초등국어수업담화에서 불연속 통어의 격률에 관한 연구/박사/서울대학교 대학원/국어교육과/2011
- [5] [학술지(정기간행물)] 김종철/흥부와 놀부 박의 화두: 행복과 욕망, 그리고 선악/선청어문/2008/36/45~67/서울대 국어교육과/
- [6] [학술지(정기간행물)] 우한용/문학교육과 도덕성 발달의 의미망/문학교육학/2004/(14)/11~40/한국문학교육학회/
- [7] [학술지(정기간행물)] 정재찬/문학교육과 도덕적 상상력/문학교육학/2004/(14)/41~78/한국문학교육학회/
- [8] [단행본] Adorno’s Nietzschean Narratives: Critiques of Ideology, Reading of Wagner/Bauer, Karin/SUNY Press/1999/~///
- [9] [단행본] Classroom Discourse: The Language of Teaching and Learning(2nd ed.)/Cazden, C. B./Heinemann/2001/~///
- [10] [단행본] 담론의 질서/Foucault, M/새길/2011/~///
- [11] [학술지(정기간행물)] Geertz, C./Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight/Daedalus/1972/101(1)/1~37//
- [12] [단행본] The Interpretation of Cultures/Geertz, C./Basic Books/1973/~///
- [13] [단행본] Edmund Husserl’s Phenomenology, Purdue University Series in the History of Philosophy/Kockelmans, J. J./Purdue University Press/1994/~///
- [14] [단행본] Structural Anthropology/Levi-Strauss, C/Basic Books/1963/~///
- [15] [단행본] 비극의 탄생/Nietzsche, F./아카넷/2008/~///
- [16] [단행본] Children and Books(8th ed.)/Sutherland, A/New York Harper Collins Publishers/1991/~///
- [17] [단행본] 미학의 기본 개념사/Tatarkiewicz, W/미술문화/1999/~///
