Misunderstanding, Fear, and Humor — A Ricoeurian Hermeneutic Reading of <The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon>
JANG YOUNG CHANG
한국연구재단
Korea Business Review 60Vol. 5No. pp.101-132 (2025)
Abstract
This study analyzes the Korean folktale The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon through Paul Ricoeur’s hermeneutic theory, focusing on the concepts of triple mimesis (Mimesis I–II–III) and narrative identity. While the tale is typically viewed as a humorous anecdote centered on misunderstanding, this paper argues that its narrative structure reveals deeper processes through which fear, misinterpretation, and imagination reshape both meaning and subjectivity. By applying Ricoeur’s framework, the study reframes the tale not simply as comic folklore but as a narrative that generates a transformation of emotion and self-understanding. The study first situates the tale within its cultural and narrative context, noting that the tiger traditionally functions in Korean folklore as an “absolute agent of fear.” At the level of Mimesis I, the cultural code that equates the tiger with fear is disrupted when the child immediately stops crying at the mention of the dried persimmon. This moment fractures the symbolic order and opens a space for a new configuration of meaning. At the level of Mimesis II, the plot develops through a chain of escalating misunderstandings involving the crying child, the tiger’s alliance with the bear, and the mistaken assumptions made at the marketplace. These accumulated misreadings transfer meaning onto the signifier “dried persimmon,” forming what Ricoeur calls a “discordant concordance”—a narrative unity created out of irrational perceptions and repeated misinterpretations. In the stage of Mimesis III, the audience reconfigures both fear and meaning through laughter. The tiger’s transformation—from a fearsome predator into a creature terrified of a simple persimmon—enables the listener to experience a shift in emotional orientation and self-understanding. Humor becomes a hermeneutic event that reveals the constructed nature of fear and identity, demonstrating how narrative can transform perception of the world and of oneself. Through this Ricoeurian analysis, the study shows that the tale functions not merely as folklore but as a narrative device that integrates utterance, misunderstanding, imagination, and reception. The findings highlight the tale’s value as a site of hermeneutic reflection, suggesting that similar folktales across East Asia may also embody comparable narrative movements from fear to humor. This approach contributes to broader discussions of narrative identity, emotion, and the interpretive processes of oral storytelling traditions.
Keywords
Narrative identitytriple mimesismisunderstanding and humorrefiguration of emotionKorean folktale hermeneutics
References
- [1] [단행본] Time and Narrative, Vol. 1/Ricoeur, P./Moonji Publishing/1999/~///
- [2] [단행본] Time and Narrative, Vol. 3/Ricoeur, P./Moonji Publishing/2004/~///
- [3] [단행본] The Conflict of Interpretations/Ricoeur, P./Acanet/2001/~///
- [4] [단행본] Oneself as Another/Ricoeur, P./Dongmunseon/2006/~///
- [5] [학위논문] Cho, H. R./A Study on the Structure, Meaning, and Educational Use of the Folktale “<The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon>”/Master/Korea National University of Education//2002
- [6] [인터넷자원] Encyclopedia of Korean Oral Literature/https://kdp.aks.ac.kr/gubi//20251125//
- [7] [학술지(정기간행물)] Han, Y. J./An analysis of regional similarities in tiger folktales by transmission period using text-mining/Ewha Journal of Language and Literature/2024/62/23~58//
- [8] [학술지(정기간행물)] Hwang, I. D./A comparative study of the folktale “The Persimmon More Frightening than the Tiger.”/Korean Folklore Studies/2005/42/28~376//
- [9] [학술지(정기간행물)] Hwang, Y. J./Understanding <The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon> as a narrative of conflict between nature and culture/Studies in Oral Literature/2024/71/41~148//
- [10] [학위논문] Jeong, S. H./A Study of Folkloric Imagination in the Formation of Early Korean Children’s Literature: Focusing on the Fairy Tales of Sohn Jin-tae, Ko Han-seung, and Ma Hae-song/Doctor/Korea University, Graduate School//2025
- [11] [학위논문] Kim, H. H./A Study on the Types and Meanings of Tiger Folktales through Fear and Anxiety Psychology/Doctor/Konkuk University Graduate School, Seoul.//2023
- [12] [학술지(정기간행물)] Kim, S. Y./The narrative of primal anxiety and healing: <The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon>/Journal of Literary Therapy/2014/32/76~77/Korean Society for Literary Therapy/
- [13] [학위논문] Lee, S. J./A Study for Rewriting “<The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon>”/Master/Korea National University of Education/Graduate School of Education/2015
- [14] [단행본] Time and Narrative, Vol. 1/Ricoeur, P./Moonji Publishing/1999/~///
- [15] [단행본] Time and Narrative, Vol. 3/Ricoeur, P./Moonji Publishing/2004/~///
- [16] [단행본] The Conflict of Interpretations/Ricoeur, P./Acanet/2001/~///
- [17] [단행본] Oneself as Another/Ricoeur, P./Dongmunseon/2006/~///
- [18] [학술지(정기간행물)] Sung, K. Y./A study on Korean oral transmission: The case of <The Tiger and the Dried Persimmon>/Korean Studies Review/1989/1/22~45/Inha University Institute of Korean Studies/
- [19] [학술지(정기간행물)] /////~//
- [20] [인터넷자원] https://kdp.aks.ac.kr/gubi/https://kdp.aks.ac.kr/gubi//20251125//
